Report to: Adult Social Care and Community Safety Scrutiny Committee
Date: 19 March 2015
By: Director of Adult Social Care and Health
Title of Report: Older people’s directly provided day services
Purpose of Report: To update committee on the tender for service provision at the Isabel Blackman Centre, Phoenix Centre and Charter Centre following the conclusion of a tendering process.
RECOMMENDATIONS
The Committee is recommended to note:
3. That an oral update will be made at the meeting on further progress.
1. Financial Appraisal
1.1 There are no additional financial implications arising from this report. The full year effect of savings achieved to date from Phase 1, from the closure of three units and net of client re-provisioning costs, total £417,984 (2015/16 budget). Further savings will be achieved once the future use of the buildings has been made. Details are set out in Appendix 1.
1.2 With further savings of £344,000 planned from Phase 2 a total of £761,984 annual savings will result from Phases 1 and 2.
2. Background and Supporting Information
Cabinet Decisions
2.1 On 10th December 2013 Cabinet agreed to close the Orion Centre - Hailsham, Pinehill – Hastings and Hookstead Centre – Crowborough. These services have now been closed and clients re-provided with alternative services. Cabinet also agreed to seek alternative providers to manage the buildings and deliver a day services at the Isabel Blackman Centre – Hastings, the Charter Centre – Bexhill and the Phoenix Centre – Lewes. On 13th November 2014 Adult Social Care and Community Safety Committee received a report on Developing the Market, Appendix 4 of that report provided an update on Day Services Review Outcomes.
Tender Process
2.2 A full tender commenced in August 2014 with bids returned in November. Bids were evaluated and the successful organisation, Sussex Community Development Agency (SCDA) was informed in January 2015. The tender was constructed so that bidders could offer to provide services at any or all of the locations. SCDA bid for and were successful in all three locations.
2.3 As a consequence of the similarity between the current services and the tendered services, Transfer of Undertakings - Protection of Employment (TUPE) regulations apply. This means that a number of current staff will continue to provide services through the transition and into the future and that therefore clients will have continuity and minimal disruption. Approximately 30 staff will potentially transfer to the new provider from either the County Council or from Age UK.
2.4 The contract moves to a ”spot purchase” mechanism where the County Council pays for individual service user attendance. This avoids high unit costs as the rate per day is fixed by the contract. This reduces risk for the authority and avoids the payment of voids for non-attendance that can be associated with a block contract. The contract also requires the provider to manage the buildings. This allows for income generation on the part of the provider and the ability to market services to self-funding clients, thereby offering a more sustainable business model than total reliance on a council contract for day services.
Strategic Context
2.5 The approach described above has been taken within the Council Operating Principles to use Strategic Commissioning ‘to deliver appropriate services to secure the best outcomes and value for money for residents’, thereby keeping vulnerable people safe and making the best use of our resources. Working with voluntary and community sector providers also supports strong partnerships in developing the market, resulting in greater choice for clients and improved value for money. Costs have been reduced as have financial risks to the Council.
Engagement and Specification
2.6 High levels of engagement with clients, carers and staff took place prior to, during and after the consultation period. Clients and carers were invited to contribute to the new service specification in order to ensure that any concerns about new services would be considered and addressed. Appendix 2 gives a summary of the process and examples of the returned forms. Appendix 3 provides key information from the service specification.
3. Current position
3.1 Work is ongoing to quantify pension liabilities and responsibilities in advance of formal signing of contracts. These are complex arrangements and the scale of the staff transfer is significant. SCDA is working with Age UK and County Council on transition planning. SCDA has employed a project manager to support this transition. Joint communications have been agreed between agencies for staff, clients and carers. Once the pensions issue has been resolved the contracts can be signed and transition arrangements put in place.
3.2 Throughout the transition, all day services will continue to be provided without disruption. As staff TUPE into the new services, continuity will be provided for clients. All three units have some usage by external agencies. SCDA has agreed that these arrangements will continue unchanged during the transition period and any future changes will involve discussions with these agencies. Transport arrangements will continue as they have previously been provided. This will also support continuity. The transition will include staff consultation of 30 days.
3.3 Following transition, as with Phase 1, market development will continue to develop and support new services, in line with the Cabinet decision.
4. Conclusion and Reasons for Recommendations
4.1 This report further updates for Committee on day services changes, as requested on 13 November 2014.
4.2 A successful provider has been identified and offered the contracts for all three day services and buildings management. Work is ongoing to agree TUPE arrangements for County Council staff. Appendix 4 provides detail about the tender process. SCDA has appointed transition staff and is attending communication events at each of the centres in order to progress planning arrangements.
4.3 Savings targets continue to be on track and will be confirmed at the point of contract commencement. Throughout transition and into contract management, close monitoring and support will be used to achieve a smooth transfer to the new services with as little disruption as possible for current clients, carers and staff.
KEITH HINKLEY
Director of Adult Social Care and Health
Contact Officer: Barry Atkins, Head of Strategic Commissioning Tel No: 01273 482308
Phase 1: Day Services savings summary
2015/16 |
Net Budget |
Reprovisioning Costs |
Net Savings |
|
£ |
£ |
£ |
Hookstead |
224,500 |
46,592 |
177,908 |
Orion |
197,600 |
87,360 |
110,240 |
Pinehill |
319,300 |
189,464 |
129,836 |
TOTAL |
741,400 |
323,416 |
417,984 |
Phase 2: Day Services savings summary
Full Year Projected Saving |
|
|
£ |
Charter |
88,000 |
Phoenix |
62,000 |
Isabel Blackman |
194,000 |
Total |
344,000 |
1.1 The full actual cost of re-commissioning Phase 2 will not be known until transfer takes place. The figures are based on an assumption that current levels of service will continue.
1.2 For both Phase 1 and Phase 2 there has been a move away from a fully funded service (the service having a fixed annual budget and regardless of attendance levels) to a ‘spot purchased’ contract where ESC ASC&H pays for individual attendance sessions. This reduces the risk for the council and provides transparency in terms of costs to the client.
1.3 Estimated savings forecast combined for Phase 1 and Phase 2 are £761,984.
Engagement Summary
1.1 As part of the County Council’s 2013 – 2015 Reconciling Policy Performance and Resources process, older people’s directly provided day services were reviewed, these were:
· Orion, Hailsham
· Pinehill, Hastings
· Hookstead, Crowborough
· Phoenix Centre, Lewes
· Isabel Blackman Centre (IBC), Hastings
· Charter Centre, Bexhill-on-Sea
1.2 As part of this review, a 90 day consultation with clients, carers, staff and key stakeholders took place between July and October 2013. The scale of the consultation was significant, involving over 200 clients and their carers, at least 50 staff and a wide mix of key stakeholders. More than 780 responses were received to the day centre consultation and each were responded to. The commissioning team and directly provided services worked collaboratively in managing the consultation which was at times both challenging and emotional. At least two meetings were offered to staff, clients and carers at each of the units. Carers and clients were invited to complete a form that highlighted the key elements of the specification and asked for views. These were collated and used to inform the drafting of the service specification.
1.3 There had been a series of meetings with staff and clients before the formal consultation and following the consultation meetings were held to informed clients and carers of the outcomes. Carers in particular were assured that their views would inform the service specification as some concerns had been raised regarding the potential impact of any changes.
1.4 People were invited to contribute to the consultation in the following ways:
Day Services - Specification (Key Headings) – Sample responses:
Please use the boxes below to write any suggestions / comments under the appropriate key heading(s) for consideration when developing service specifications.
Key Heading |
Comments |
Hours of service |
|
Activities |
|
Community engagement / Social needs |
|
Dietary needs |
|
Transport |
|
Equality and diversity |
|
Religious, cultural and spiritual needs |
|
Communication needs |
|
Accessibility needs / Physical environment |
|
Information and Advice |
|
Other (please indicate) |
|
Other (please indicate) |
|
Other (please indicate) |
|
East Sussex County Council Department for Adult Social Care
Tender for the Provision of Day Opportunities in the Isabel Blackman Centre, Hastings, the Charter Centre, Bexhill and the Phoenix Centre, Lewes
This specification sets out the quality and standards of the services required by East Sussex County Council’s (ESCC) Adult Social Care (ASC) Department for the provision of day opportunities. The standards set out in these documents are the minimum requirements.
The main outcome we want to achieve through this service is to enable older people to remain living independently in the community.
The outcomes of the service will be achieved by providing a broad range of activities either directly by the Service Provider or indirectly through other organisations.
These services will be designed to meet individual needs and provide timely and appropriate support and respite to Carers to enable them to continue in their role as carer.
A range of activities will be made available for Clients. These will, as far as is possible, reflect the needs of the local community and be tailored to address the specific preferences expressed by the Client as detailed on the individual’s Care and Support Plan (Reference 4.2).
The activities should not be limited to taking place in one building, and should include supporting the Client, as far as is possible, to access social and leisure opportunities in the local community.
The service should be available to older people (over 65) who may be in the early stages of dementia, or who have physical disabilities, sensory impairment and/or long term conditions. The service provider should have the necessary resources to meet the support needs of this client group, and any premises used for activities need to be accessible for all clients.
Clients should also be supported to manage their own health and social care as far as is practical.
Individuals’ choices and preferences should be observed with respect to friendship groups.
Regular surveys of clients’ activity preferences and their opinions on the services will be undertaken and recorded.
The provider will work in partnership with providers in health, social care and the voluntary sector and other partners.
Where possible the service should offer flexible operating hours which may include drop in sessions / shorter hours, extended hours, emergency respite and weekends which meet the needs of Clients and their Carers.
Clear information will be provided on the cost and quality of services, so people can make informed choices.
The overall service outcome is to deliver a range of services which will enable Clients to:
· maintain and increase control over their daily life;
· maintain personal cleanliness;
· live safely and as independently as possible;
· improve their quality of life;
· participate as active members of the community.
Specific service outcomes include but are not limited to;
· contributing to the maintenance of independence;
· contributing to the reduction of social isolation;
· providing relief and respite for Carers;
· providing opportunities for integration with activities in the wider community including client volunteering, as appropriate;
· the enrichment of Clients quality of life;
· the provision of nutritious meals;
· assisting the maintenance or enhancement of physical and mental skills;
· rebuilding of self-confidence
· improvement of physical health, and mental and emotional well-being;
· ensuring that Clients are able to exercise their rights to choice and preferences;
The following teams in ESCC will work in partnership with the provider:
The referral process from ESCC to the Provider takes place as follows:
The Service Provider will ensure Clients have, as far as is possible, control of the decisions about their life and the services they receive and have access to resources to support them in making decisions to meet the agreed outcomes in their individual Care and Support Plan.
The provider should conduct all activity with the ethos of personalised services in mind. This may include, but is not limited to, the provision of:
· Low level advocacy, e.g. supporting clients with correspondence
· Choice of activities
· Choice regarding how and by whom support is provided
· Choice about who is involved and control over what decisions are made at meetings and reviews regarding their personal welfare.
· Informed choice and control over risk taking and management of risk.
· ‘This is me bag’ – Designed for people with dementia, this collection of documents is compiled with the Client and provides information about their individual needs, preferences, likes, dislikes and interests, providing professionals with a better understanding of the individual impact of dementia.
The Provider will work with the client to identify reablement goals and potential, providing ‘just enough’ support to enable the client to develop greater independence and plan ahead for goals that may expand their support away from the Provider.
Policies and procedures will be in place to support respect and dignity. The Service Provider will ensure that Clients are free from any form of discrimination, harassment, abuse and neglect and that their human rights shall be protected.
The Service Provider will ensure that Clients are treated with respect and dignity at all times and will ensure that no Client is excluded on the grounds of race, gender, religion, ethnicity, sexual orientation or for any other discriminatory reason.
Client’s faith, beliefs, ethnicity, disability and sexual orientation will be respected. This respect will include the way support is provided and the way services are accessed and delivered, and will take into account any preferences regarding mode of address.
Clients will be advised of their responsibility to treat others with respect and dignity.
Religious, Cultural and Spiritual Needs
The Service Provider will ensure that the religious, cultural and spiritual needs of individual Clients are recorded in the Care and Support Plan and are respected.
Staff working for the Service Provider will be trained and informed of the differing cultural and religious beliefs or faiths of Clients and be aware of any implications in respect of meeting their support and dietary requirements.
It will not be assumed that an individual Client identified as belonging to a particular faith or religion follows the traditional belief system and, therefore, all aspects of the individual’s needs will be identified in their Care and Support Plan and be agreed, discussed and regularly reviewed with them.
Clients will, as far as is practicable, be given the opportunity to support and to keep in touch with their faith communities and be supported by staff to observe any religious ceremony and festivals.
Any perceived incidents of discrimination, racism or exclusion will be documented and acted upon by the Service Provider in accordance with the appropriate policy or procedure relating to the service(refer to clause 3.3 in the contract terms and conditions).
This service will be provided in a manner which safeguards Clients privacy in line with their personal choices and in compliance with the Data Protection Act, Freedom of Information Act, The Mental Capacity Bill and the Department’s confidentiality policy.
Privacy will, as far as is practical, include Clients having control over who has access to personal information held about them and being able to discuss their needs in confidence and in private. Policies and procedures should reflect the need to support an individual’s privacy.
Safeguarding Vulnerable Adults and Children
The Service Provider must ensure that clients are safeguarded from any form of abuse or exploitation, meeting the standards and regulations set out in:
The Service Provider will ensure that they recognise the Clients right to take risk in order to extend opportunities and in doing so ensure that they are given support to help them understand the implications of risk taking.
Clients will be protected from any form of bullying, harassment or any other form of abuse.
Full investigations will be conducted for reported incidents or accidents and when appropriate these will be referred on to external agencies.
Risk assessments will be undertaken when arranging trips and community based activities.
There will be appropriate numbers of trained staff on duty to deal with any accidents or incidents.
Clients will have risks discussed with them for all activities which may be deemed as carrying an element of risk. Individuals will be supported to take informed risks, within a risk assessment framework which will strive for best practice and risk reduction. Any information regarding the risk assessment framework will be displayed in a clear and unobstructed manner that can be easily accessed by the Client.
Fire Evacuation Risks will be assessed by the Service Provider as part of the standard Risk Assessment Procedure.
Clients must give their permission before any healthcare concerns the staff may have about them are discussed with the family / Carer or outside agency (i.e. GP). In the case of a medical emergency the Clients health and safety is paramount and it is accepted that a decision may need to be made in the best interests of the Client (i.e. calling an ambulance or in order to protect a vulnerable person who in particular situations may lack capacity under the terms of the Mental Capacity Act 2005.
Arrangements will be in place to support the Client to remember to take any necessary medication. If any staff administer medication, they must be trained to do so and this will be within the remit of the Service Provider’s medication policy and procedures which will be robust and reviewed annually.
In case of crisis, the Service Provider will be supplied with information about each Client’s medical history, current healthcare needs and potential health risks on a “need to know basis” in order to provide a safe service and support when responding to healthcare needs.
Self-management of healthcare and healthy lifestyles will be encouraged; this may include encouraging immunisations / screenings / regular checkups or referral to the fall prevention schemes.
Where possible, Clients will not be excluded from activities as a result of an identified healthcare need. In these circumstances, risks will be discussed with the individual Client and necessary adaptations to the activity should be made for the individual. The scope and remit of staff medical intervention will be made clear at the onset of any service delivery.
Clients will be supported to communicate at the speed and in a manner they choose.
The individual Clients communication needs will be identified and addressed in the Care and Support Plan and regularly updated and reviewed.
Where appropriate, staff will be trained in the use of sign language and with communication aids and techniques. Where such specialists and/or interpreters are required, access to these services will be arranged by the Service Providers.
Staff should have access to health care professionals who specialise in speech and language therapies and advice. In such cases the GP and the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) should be approached for advice.
The families / Carers of individuals with communication needs should, with the permission of the Client, be requested to support the service in understanding the needs of the individual.
Record and communication books should be adopted between families / Carers, staff and those Clients who have communication difficulties due to memory retention problems.
Meal Provision & Dietary Needs
Clients will be offered the choice of a hot lunch time meal.
All dietary needs will be met, this may include: diabetic, gluten free, wheat free, vegetarian, vegan and low fat.
Regular refreshments must always be available, this may include: fresh water, juices, tea, coffee, hot chocolate and the options of fresh fruit.
All food and drink will be prepared in compliance with current food and hygiene standards.
Support and information will be available on healthy nutrition and lifestyles to support improved health; this will include a balanced diet of freshly cooked meals.
The Service Provider should source from local suppliers where possible,
The Service Provider will provide opportunities for the Client to use the service as a stepping stone to enable them to engage in community activities and events where these have been identified as being a beneficial part of their delivery of care and improved quality of life.
The Service Provider and East Sussex County Council will need to agree how any transport element of the service will be provided.
Transporters will be fully trained in the movement of less able people in and out of the vehicles.
Any vehicles used will meet all legal insurance requirements.
East Sussex County Council Adult Social Care Department wishes to work in partnership with Service Providers in delivering a high quality of care to its Clients. The Department hopes to maximise the use of available resources by establishing longer-term, more integrated relationships with Service Providers in the independent, community and voluntary sector.
The Department and Service Providers are making a commitment to:
· Share key objectives
· Collaborate for mutual benefit
· Communicate with each other clearly and regularly
· Be open and honest with each other, to respect parties’ views and to conduct themselves in a professional manner
· Listen to, and understand, each other’s point of view
· Share relevant information, expertise and plans
· Avoid duplicating service provision with other providers wherever possible
· Provide opportunities to give feedback on the performance of both parties
· Seek to avoid conflicts but, where they arise, to resolve them quickly at a local level
· Seek continuous improvement by working together in order to achieve optimum benefit from the resources available and by identifying better, more efficient ways of working and delivering services
· Promote the partnership approach at all levels in both organisations (e.g. through joint induction/training initiatives)
· Have a contract, which is flexible enough to reflect changing needs, priorities and lessons learnt, and which encourages Clients participation.
These principles represent an attempt at defining the spirit of partnership within which the Department and Service Providers will operate.
Staffing and Training
The service will be managed on a day-to-day basis by a “named” person who has relevant experience and/or appropriate qualifications in the field of social care, i.e. QCF NVQ Diploma in Health and Social Care Level 2 and above.
Ensure sufficient management time is available to provide effective management of the Service including regular individual and group supervision.
Staff without Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks should not at any time be left unsupervised in sole charge of an individual Client, a group of Clients or a service (e.g. volunteers or new starters).
Staff will focus on ‘doing with’ rather than ‘doing to’ and will be trained and skilled in helping Clients to maintain and enhance their independence wherever possible.
The Service Provider shall ensure the presence of sufficient appropriately trained staff on duty at any given time to ensure a safe ratio to the number of Clients. The actual number will be dependent on the Clients needs. A minimum of 1:7 shall be provided where the Clients have low level of needs and 1:5 where Clients have special needs e.g. wheelchair users; living with dementia; sensory impairment. These ratios will usually exclude the ancillary staff, visiting staff and voluntary helpers.
Staff ratios must be flexible and take into account the changing needs of Clients, environmental factors and any specific activities requiring varying staffing levels e.g. trips to community facilities or day trips.
The staffing level established must be maintained in all circumstances, including at times of staff absence as a result of sickness or holidays and a system will be in place to arrange cover for any expected staff absences and, as far as is practicable, any unexpected staff absences.
Staff skills will be evaluated at supervision sessions and a plan will be devised for personal development, which is based on the needs of the service.
All staff will be trained in health and safety prior to commencement of duties and this will include;
· Fire Safety
· Basic First Aid
· Food Hygiene (where appropriate)
· Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (COSHH).
In addition staff who have more direct contact with clients will be trained in the following prior to commencement of duties:
· Infection Control
· Manual Handling
The Service Provider will ensure that staff are provided with equipment, facilities and training to conduct their role safely.
The Service will be monitored by staff in the Strategic Commissioning and Contracts and Purchasing teams within ASC.
The Provider will need to demonstrate that:
· Activity levels match billing (evidenced through storage of daily client sign-in registers)
· Client outcomes are being achieved
· Service quality is of a good standard
Detailed below is an example of some of the data to be collected and recorded by the Service Provider, and made available to ASC quarterly. Targets will be agreed on a service by service basis.
Key Performance Process Indicators |
Number of referrals received |
Number of referrals who declined to receive a service |
Number of referrals not accommodated by provider |
|
No. of Clients accessing the service at start of Qtr |
No. of Clients who commenced service during Qtr |
No. of Clients who stopped receiving service during Qtr |
No. of Clients accessing service at end of the Qtr |
|
Number of days service operating |
Service capacity (days service operating x capacity) |
|
Number of Individual Plans of Care agreed |
Percentage of Clients contacted within 48 hours of the initial ASC Referral |
Percentage of Clients visited within one week of ASC Referral |
Percentage of Clients receiving a service after two weeks of first contact from the Service Provider. |
Percentage of Individual Plans of Care agreed with Clients within 4 weeks of referral |
Key Performance Output Indicator |
Number of Clients who received a service during the Qtr |
Attendance (Clients x days service provided) |
|
Number of reviews completed |
|
Number of Client satisfaction surveys completed |
% of Clients satisfied by the range of activities provided |
% of Clients satisfied by the choice of food available |
|
Key Performance Outcome Indicators |
Percentage of people who report improvement in knowing where to get more information and who to ask for help |
Percentage of people who feel their health is better than 3 months ago |
Percentage of people who report an improvement in the quality of their life |
Percentage of people who think they received what they needed from this service |
Percentage of people who feel the service made them more confident |
Percentage of people who feel the service has made their life easier |
Key Performance Workforce Indicators |
Number of WTE staff employed at start of Qtr |
Number of WTE staff who left employment during the Qtr |
Number of WTE staff who started employment during the Qtr |
Number of WTE staff employed at the end of the Qtr |
Number of volunteers |
% compliance with induction training for new staff |
% compliance with ongoing training for staff / to National Minimum Standards |
Other information required |
Information on all incidents/accidents and safeguarding alerts |
Information on complaints and compliments |
Records will be available for auditing purposes at the commissioners’ request.
As part of the monitoring review and evaluation of this service, ASC staff may require sight of any statements, policies or procedural documentation relating to any of the sections set out within this Service Standards which will include, but not be limited to:
· Insurance and indemnity policies
· Staffing records
· Training schedules
· DBS records
· Client information
· Health & Safety policy
The Service Provider will demonstrate that it monitors and regularly receives feedback about Client satisfaction. Examples may include:
· Survey sent out to Client using pre-paid questionnaires
· Individual comments to the Service Provider via letter or in person
· Quarterly Client Forums
· Complaints received
· Compliments received
· Action taken by the Service Provider with respect to complaints and compliments.
Using a full range of consultation mechanisms the Service Provider is expected to gauge:
· Client’s views on the Service Provider
· Whether the Service Provider has achieved the outcomes the Client had expected to be delivered.
· Client’s ideas on improving the day service
· Whether Clients and their families/Carers;
o are confident that they are fully supported to exercise choice and control over their lives in all aspects of their Day Opportunities service.
o are confident that they are treated with dignity and that their individuality is respected in all aspects of the Day Opportunities service.
o are confident that their right to privacy is respected at all times in all aspects of their Day Opportunities service.
o feel safe at the Day Opportunities service and they understand their rights and responsibilities.
o feel that there is a good range of activities which are based on individual preferences and are tailored to meet individual need.
o feel that healthcare needs are supported by the Provider and that they are treated with dignity and respect at all times
o feel that individuality and diversity is respected and embraced
o are confident that communication techniques have been adopted which maximise the flow of communication between the Day Opportunities service and the individual.
o feel that the individual is afforded opportunities to establish and maintain community activity and involvement and are supported to do so where appropriate.
Review of the Service Specification
The service specification will be reviewed on an annual basis. Changes in legislation or improvement in practices may result in modification. The Service Provider shall be fully consulted with regard to any proposed changes.
Buildings and Facilities Management Specification
Context
This specification sets out the quality and standards of the buildings and facilities aspect required by East Sussex County Council’s (ESCC) Adult Social Care (ASC) Department in relation to the provision of day opportunities. The standards set out in these documents are the minimum requirements.
This specification describes the main roles and responsibilities of the Service Provider and ESCC and includes as a detailed service level agreement, scope of on-going buildings management and condition surveys for Charter, Phoenix and the Isabel Blackman Centre, the surveys also include the layout plans.
East Sussex will work with potential Service Providers on a site specific basis to optimise the use of existing resources in the building.
Details of the various organisations currently using the space in all three centres is described in appendix 3.
The Service Provider will provide the day to day management of the centre to include any potential usage by other service providers compatible with the existing day service.
The management of the building will include the Service Provider having in place and deploying a clear and detailed policy on Health and Safety. This will include ensuring all client, staff, volunteers, visitors and contractors are fully aware and understand the Health and Safety policy and procedures within.
Controllers of premises will be identified for the buildings to oversee fire, emergency, aasbestos management and other related safety arrangements, in particular the safe working of contractors with support / assistance from the ESCC Business Services Department as agreed within the contract and lease agreement.
The Service Provider will provide their own IT infrastructure and be responsible for the on-going technical support and maintenance. However, where possible East Sussex will seek to support existing IT infrastructures.
The utilities for the building will be contracted and managed in arrangements to be determined between ESCC and the Service Provider which will ensure best value and use of resources.
Furnishings already within the building can be utilised by the Service Provider with new and replacement furnishings being provided by the Service Provider.
Kitchen equipment already in place will continue to be supplied and maintained by ESSC. New and replacement equipment, this will be provided by the Service Provider (see next section for further detail).
Faults must be reported to ESCC (see next section) for the service level agreement on property maintenance).
Security will be managed by the Service Provider including the recording and reporting of any breaches of security.
Buildings Management: Organisations using the space at Charter, Phoenix and IBC
This appendix outlines the current ownership of each Centre and the various use of each building by different organisations other than ESCC, detailing associated licence arrangements.
There will be different expectations for the on-going co-ordination and management of these current partnership arrangements with the individual Centres. This will be dependent upon if organisations pay to use the space and how an organisation might add value as a community resource.
Charter Centre, Bexhill-on-Sea
The Charter Centre in Bexhill is located in a building which includes sheltered housing flats, a base for the British Red Cross and offices for the local Joint Community Reablement Service. The County Council has a 99 year lease agreement with Amicus Horizon Housing who own the building.
There are currently 5 different organisations who occupy some of the space at the Charter Centre at different times, these are:
Memorandum of Occupation licence arrangements are in place between ESCC and all these individual organisations and were renewed in July 2014 (at a peppercorn rent). They include a clause stating a one month termination by either party or immediately, or if there had been a breach of the agreement terms.
Future arrangements
These organisations are considered as adding value to the local community, therefore there would be an expectation that the new provider managing the building will work in partnership to enable the continued shared use of space by these organisations. Any requests to change the current arrangement, or if there are any new organisations wishing to occupy the space, should be made in writing to the ASC commissioning department.
Isabel Blackman Centre, Hastings
The Isabel Blackman Centre (IBC) is currently owned by ESCC and was re-developed in partnership with the voluntary sector into a “Community Hub” in 2010. This model of service is predominantly but not exclusively focused on the needs of older people in the Hastings area. The centre is managed by the voluntary sector (a partnership arrangement between SCDA who operate the café & Age UK manage the building and day service) with a core Care Managed Day Opportunities service currently led by ESCC seconded staff for a designated cohort of Clients.
Future arrangements
Arrangements for organisations that use / rent the space at the IBC are made directly between the voluntary sector (currently Age UK and SCDA) and it is envisaged that any existing or new arrangements would continue to be managed directly between any new provider and the organisations.
The Phoenix Centre is a purpose-built day service in Lewes, owned by the County Council. A Deed of Covenant was entered into by the League of friends of Phoenix Centre with the County Council and dated 12 June 1991 in respect of the extension to the Phoenix Centre. This restricts the use to which the extension may be put, and provides for what will happen in the event that it ceases to be used for such a purpose.
There are currently 16 different organisations who occupy some of the space at the Phoenix Centre at different times, these are:
|
· Mindfulness Group / Memory Clinic · Care for the Carers · Lewes District Seniors · The Talking Newspaper · Canine Concern · Private Foot Care practitioners · Outside caring agencies i.e. Care Watch providing bathing service · Blue Badge Clinic |
Future arrangements
There is an informal arrangement for the use of space occupied by all of these organisations who pay a nominal rental to ESCC, therefore there may be potential for a voluntary & community organisation to increase the rate for rent and generate income. It is therefore suggested that the new provider takes on the on-going management and co-ordination of these groups including new booking requests.
Background
Following the identification of the requirement for the continuation of day services at the Isabel Blackman Centre (Hastings), the Phoenix Centre (Lewes) and the Charter Centre (Bexhill), a decision was taken to approach the market and tender. This decision has been made in accordance for both internal policy and external, European Union Procurement regulations. The Tender for the Provision of Day Services within East Sussex falls into this category.
The Council carried out a Restricted Tender process for this procurement activity.
Following 28 expressions of interest, 7 organisations submitted a pre-qualification questionnaire (PQQ). Of these 7, 3 were invited to tender following a panel evaluation.
Evaluation
1. Introduction
1.1. The aim of the evaluation was to identify organisations with the capacity and capability to provide the service tendered for.
1.2. The deadline for the receipt of tenders was 14th November 2014 and the evaluation criterion was agreed in advance of this. It was agreed that the tenders would be scored as 80% with respect to quality and 20% with respect to finance. The price scoring would be undertaken by Strategic Finance, Stella Armstrong taking the lead.
1.3. Following initial evaluation all bidders were invited to Bid Clarification meetings.
2. Panel Members
2.1. The procurement panel of council officers were supported by groups of ‘Experts by Experience’ representing each of the centres.
3. Evaluation Criteria
3.1. The evaluation criterion was tailored to suit this tender and was weighted as follows;
Operations |
25% |
Quality |
17% |
Safeguarding & Risk |
13% |
Workforce |
20% |
Buildings Management |
5% |
Price |
20% |
3.2. In accordance with best practice, method statement questions based on evaluation criteria were included in the I.T.T questionnaire. For the evaluation criteria, the following scoring system was used:
0 Unacceptable
1 – 2 Serious deficiencies
3 - 4 Some deficiencies
5 - 6 Acceptable
7 – 8 Good
9 – 10 Very good
4. Financial Appraisal
4.1. The providers have been appraised by Strategic Finance and responded to Financial Clarification questions.
[1] The Service Placement Team is a County Council service that supports practitioner to achieve best value in purchasing services for adults eligible for Adult Social Care funding. They also provide advice and support for practitioners to share with clients on using Personal Budgets to purchase services